MYFRESHTOOLS
50% OFF
YouTube › Channel audit

How to Find Underperforming YouTube Videos

Underperforming only means something compared with something. Here are four useful yardsticks and how to apply them.

Updated 24 October 2026 · 8 min read
Quick answer
To find underperforming YouTube videos, compare each video's views with its age and with your channel's average, rather than with a fixed number. In YouTube Studio, sort Content by Views and read it next to upload dates; for a ranked shortlist by age, format, likes, comments and share of your average, scan your channel with MyFreshTools Bulk Video Visibility Manager and apply the filters together.

“Underperforming” sounds objective, but it's a comparison in disguise. A video with 600 views is a hit on one channel and a miss on another, and a video that's been live for three days hasn't underperformed anything yet.

To get a list worth acting on, choose a yardstick first. This guide covers four, how to apply each in YouTube Studio or a scan, and what to do with the result.

Choose a yardstick

Four ways to define underperforming

YardstickQuestion it answersBest for
Views vs. ageHas it had time to find an audience, and still hasn't?Any channel — the baseline
Views vs. your channel averageIs it far below what your typical video gets?Channels with a settled audience
Likes and commentsDo the people who watch it react at all?Spotting weak content, not just weak reach
FormatIs it a Short or a long video?Comparing like with like

Likes and comments are only meaningful when YouTube returns them. If a creator hides the like count or switches off comments, the value is unknown, not zero, and a good tool treats it that way.

The manual way

Reading it in YouTube Studio

Open Content → Videos

Sort by Views ascending to put the quietest videos first.

Read the date column

Cross out anything recent; it hasn't had a fair run.

Estimate your average

The video list doesn't calculate your channel average for you, so you'd work it out from your analytics.

Check each candidate's analytics

Open a video's analytics to see whether views came from search, suggestions or elsewhere.

It's the right depth for a few suspects. For a channel-wide read, you need the comparison done for you.

The faster way

Filter the whole channel against your own average

Scan your channel

Connect once. The overview shows your channel's average views and how your videos spread across view ranges.

Start with age and views

Use Quiet & old as a baseline, or enter your own numbers.

Add Format

Look at Shorts and long videos separately, so one doesn't distort the other.

Go relative (paid)

On a paid plan, filter for videos below a percentage of your channel's average views — for example under 25% — and add likes or comments limits to find content that's both quiet and unreacted-to.

Protect and decide

Protect anything you want to keep, then choose what to do with the rest.

Why “share of average” helps

It moves with your channel. As your typical video gets more views, the bar for “quiet” rises automatically, without you re-typing a number.
After the list

What to do with an underperformer

  • Improve it: new title, new thumbnail, better opening, an updated description.
  • Regroup it: add it to a playlist with related videos that do well.
  • Leave it: if it's recent, or serves a small audience that values it.
  • Hide it: unlist it so it leaves search and your channel page but stays linkable, or make it private if it should vanish.

Hiding is one option out of four, and it carries no promise of lifting the rest of your channel. Use it when the video no longer represents you, not as a performance trick.

The shortcut

How MyFreshTools helps

What the tool does

It scans your uploads for free and shows views, likes, comments, age, format and visibility, with a chart of how your videos spread across view ranges and your channel average. Filters for views, age, format and title are free; likes, comments, dates and share of channel average are on paid plans.

Who it's for

Creators reviewing a back catalogue, and managers taking over a channel who need a fast, defensible list of weak spots.

How to use it for this

Open the Bulk Video Visibility Manager, connect your channel, and it scans your uploads automatically. Then:

  1. Connect your channel and read the overview.
  2. Apply Quiet & old, then add Format.
  3. On a paid plan, add likes, comments or share of channel average.
  4. Review the list and decide: improve, regroup, leave or hide.

Requirements and limits

  • A free account, and a one-time Connect YouTube. Google asks for two permissions in one screen: view your videos and stats, and change their visibility. The tool never deletes videos.
  • The free plan scans your latest 100 videos with the basic filters. Paid plans scan up to 5,000, add filters for dates, likes, comments and share of channel average, and export a CSV.
  • Scanning, previewing and restoring are free. Changing visibility costs 1 credit per video YouTube confirms; videos that fail or are skipped are never charged.
  • Up to 50 videos per batch (25 when making videos public). Bigger jobs run as repeat batches.
  • Videos scheduled to publish or still processing are skipped, and only videos on the channel you connected can be changed.
  • There is no automatic or scheduled unlisting. You choose the videos and confirm each batch.
Avoid the snags

Common mistakes and troubleshooting

What you seeLikely causeFix
Everything looks weakRecent uploads are includedAdd an age limit or protect recent uploads
Shorts dominate the listMixed formatsUse the Format filter
Likes filter excludes some videosLike counts are hidden on themUnknown counts never match, by design
Can't use share of averageIt's a paid-plan filterUse views and age on the free plan
The list is too longThe threshold is generousTighten the numbers

Frequently asked questions

Compare each video's views with its age and with your channel's average. In YouTube Studio, sort by Views and read it beside upload dates; for a combined filter, scan the channel and set views, age and format together.

There's no fixed number. It's relative: a video well below your typical views for its age and format. Fixed thresholds like 100 views are a rough starting point only.

They show reaction rather than reach. A video with views but no likes or comments may be weak content; a video with neither views nor reactions hasn't found its audience.

Yes. Scanning, filtering and previewing are free; credits are only used when you change visibility.

No. Improve, regroup or leave many of them, and unlist the ones that no longer represent your channel.

The takeaway

Define underperforming before you hunt for it. Pick a yardstick, make age and format part of it, and treat hiding as one of several honest options — not the default.


Related MyFreshTools tools